The Greatest Rock 'N' Roll Guitarist

[Monkey]

**edited by greedygrandpa**

Edited June 20, 2006 by GreedyGrandpa

[Neo52285]

the one, the only Jimmy Page

[ImmortallyInsane]

What? No Dimebag (RIP) or Zakk Wylde?

[Monkey]

**edited by greedygrandpa**

Edited June 20, 2006 by GreedyGrandpa

[ImmortallyInsane]

As far as technical skills, they probably should be on there, but they don't have the influence or impact of these guys, not to mention the popularity...

Plus, if one factors in composition skills, they don't have it. Someone like Page could improvise things (as in make something up as he goes) that most guitarists would take years to ocme up with.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yes, Page influenced many. But so did Dime, he influenced a lot of today's metal guitarists. Then again, metal isn't really a popular genre of music. Also, Dime was also good at improvising. A lot of his solo's were just off the cuff and in the moment.

[discostu]

i gotta rep the SRV although hendrix puts up a fight..

[Qball]

Hendrix, hands down.

McLaughlin is excellent, but he ain't rock'n'roll.

[Axxion]

Tough one, but I picked Petrucci over Rhoads, though I might have voted for Alexi Laiho if he was on the list...

[Barry]

i don't know much about guitars and guitar playing but to me Jimmy Page seems amazing so i have voted for him!!

[Neo52285]

i don't know much about guitars and guitar playing but to me Jimmy Page seems amazing so i have voted for him!!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

right on barry....

[Don]

Hendrix, period, not considering how incredible he was in other styles.

[the mascot]

slash, although this could be because i am listening to a lot of guns and roses at the moment

[moiselles]

Jimi Hendrix. I don't know much about rock music, but I do know he is the greatest, or one of the greats.

[Mystique]

There's five on there who's music I actually like: Brian May, David Gilmour, Jimi Hendrix, Stevie Ray Vaughn, Eric Clapton... and in the end I went with David Gilmour.

[moiselles]

I should have voted for Eddie Van Halen, he was cute back then. Love his smile.

[Red_XIII]

i play guitar (which im sure everyone does), i went with vai just cause tonight im going to see him in concert tonight, but i did have a page obsession for a while, and jimi, i love him to death, but hes completely overrated (dont kill me for this one ) i guess if it wasent for like playing tech and shit that steve vai has, id totally go with Jimmy page, amazing by all aspects, still doesnt have the chops vai does, but then again vai is a horrible song writer , SO HONESTLY I DONT NO< I LOVE JIMMY PAGE< BUT I LOVE VAI TECH PLAYING !!!!!!!

ps : if ur lookin for guitar players (jazz or just tech playing) Al Di Meola is great, check into him

[Neo52285]

thats why i dont like hendrix...he is over rated...yeah he is great but im a page fan...

and saying hendrix and page is like saying apple and oranges....well thats my opinion at least

[Monkey]

**edited by greedygrandpa**

Edited June 20, 2006 by GreedyGrandpa

[Qball]

Credit must be given to Zakk Wylde, although his achievements are tiny in comparison with legends like Hendrix, Page or Clapton. He's got great technique.

[Neo52285]

i just noticed no santana here...santana is bad ass